Page 5 of 6

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Thu Oct 24, 2013 1:55 pm
by trendwatch
**EDIT: Removed installation & downloaded and installed again. Solved!**

I tried that but there's nothing to chose from. So no Renko view available. I tried to import the renko2 indy as a view but it gets installed as an indicator and thus doesn't appear in the "view list". Can you tell me from where I can dowload the views?

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Thu Oct 24, 2013 11:00 pm
by stainer
Sorry its the new one I am using, Is it possible to get a alert for the new one.
When I asked can we get one that alerts a change of direction I ment when it prints a new brick in opposite direction.

As I said ive been using renko for about a week with some great results but its so hard to moniter more than a few currency's waiting for a new brick to print when it can happen at any time due to there being no time involved.

Thank you

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Fri Oct 25, 2013 3:18 am
by trendwatch
The new Create View version is still not working correctly! It only paints a new candle when the chosen period ends. I hoped this would be solved with this option.

So if you set the brick size to 5 and price moves 5 pips it does not paint a new brick untill the chosen chart period ends. This makes it useless in my opinion because it should be time independent. It should paint a new brick when the preset brick size is reached not when brick size is reached AND the chart period ends.

And thats not all, if price moves 20 pips up in the chart period and moves back to 3 pips the 4 bricks aren't even painted! So you can not see that price moved 4 bricks (aka 20 pips).

Just open the same Renko view in a m1 and a m5, you'll see what i mean.

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Wed Nov 06, 2013 8:08 am
by trendwatch
Any news on the malfunctioning
Create view
option? Any idea on when will this be fixed? The way it's functioning now It's completely useless.

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Thu Nov 07, 2013 4:32 am
by Apprentice
Unfortunately, no update about this issue.
Will be informed of any developments.

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 3:15 am
by GiFtzw3rg
Hello together,

the point which trendwatch is discussing is absolutly right.
The bricks are deleted when a strong counter move is appearing and the bricks are only "painted" when the choosen time period is over.

These are no Real Renko Bars. And therefor they are useless.

Apprentice or Alex Gettinger, do you have an solution for that?
I like renko but they must work correctly.

Many Thx for your help...
Greetz

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Thu Feb 20, 2014 9:30 am
by KrembuFX
Also looking forward for this.

meanwhile there is this tick renko view. viewtopic.php?f=31&t=60066

my only problem with this is that it fetch too little history from servers.

i need to leave my TSII open for about 1-2 days to get valuable data for trading

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Mon Mar 31, 2014 10:27 am
by shulya
Hello, is there any progress on the development? As stated above the indicator needs to be independent of time, otherwise it's useless.
Unfortunately it's a critical indicator for my trading style and I'll be forced to switch to Ninja Trader :?
Thanks.

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Mon Mar 31, 2014 11:53 am
by GiFtzw3rg
Hi,
i'm using Renko2 so far. My problem is that i don't know when 1 Renkobrick is closed(finished). If there were 2 Bricks long for example i thought near the pivot point this could be the trendchange. Stochastic and Ichimoku gives me the same signals. Then i go long. What happend is that when there comes a countermove the 2 white drawn Renkobricks are deleted from the charts! :o

How could this happen? Two or sometimes 3 long Renkos are deleted and drawn into a short Renko. When this happend, Stochastic and Ichimoku signals are also deleted and are showing NO Signal!

Is this a Bug? I lost some money because of this Sh..!
So when will i know if the Renkobrick is really finished and the trend goes the right direction?

Thanks for all answer
Alex

Re: Renko chart

PostPosted: Wed Apr 02, 2014 3:14 am
by Apprentice
This indicator is obsolete.
Renko.png

I encourage you to use Renko View.